A simple-minded blacksmith named Charley, well loved by the townsfolk, saves for a year to send off for a mail-order bride.

Dan Blocker
as Charley

Nanette Fabray
as Sadie

Jim Backus
as Staunch

Wally Cox
as Mr. Bester

Jack Elam
as Kittrick

Henry Jones
as Hanson

Mickey Rooney
as Indian Tom

Noah Beery Jr.
as Eddie

Stubby Kaye
as Bartender

Marge Champion
as Mrs. Bester