As a derelict paints the face of a girl on a barroom floor, the plot is developed in a series of flashbacks: Robert Stevens, an artist engaged to marry Marion, a society girl, becomes charmed with a fisherman's daughter who poses for him. The society girl's brother brings dishonor upon the fisherman's daughter, and when she commits suicide the artist shields the brother. Stevens is blamed by his fiancée, who terminates their engagement. The artist becomes a derelict and is wrongfully imprisoned. Eventually Stevens is exonerated and reunited with Marion.

Henry B. Walthall
as Robert Stevens

Ruth Clifford
as Marion Trevor

Ralph Emerson
as Dick Van Vleck

Frederick Sullivan
as Thomas Waring

Alma Bennett
as Lottie

Norval MacGregor
as Governor

Michael Dark
as Henry Drew

Gus Saville
as Fisherman