A high school teacher in the Bronx loses funding for the school musical and convinces his fellow statistics teacher—secretly a recovering gambling addict—to help him cheat at an underground card game run by the Hasidic Jewish community. The plan goes awry with mounting consequences, but help comes at an unexpected time from the least likely people.

Amnon Carmi
as The Rebbe

Ben Ducoff
as Bernstein

Catherine Curtin
as Principal O'Donnell

Eli Boskey
as Jonah

Annabel Steven
as Deb

Adam B. Shapiro
as Mendy

Rachel Luciani
as Emma Levy

Ben Salus
as Rick

Mitchell Fields
as Mickey (aka Zayde)

Nik Sadhnani
as Bez