Set on Fire Island, My Hustler depicts competition over the affections of a young male hustler among a straight woman, a former male hustler, and the man who hired the boy's companionship via a "Dial-A-Hustler" service.

Paul America
as Paul

Joseph Campbell
as Joe

Genevieve Charbon
as Genevieve

Dorothy Dean
as Woman with Lipstick

Ed Hood
as Ed

J.D. McDermott
as Kali