Noam Stein is a closeted teenager in a religious community who discovers he might not be alone. When he finds a love letter written to his grandfather by another man before the Holocaust, he sets out to find this mysterious person and uncover both his grandfather's identity as well as his own.

Charlie Korman
as Noam

Michael Zapesotsky
as Jonah

Katherine Kamhi
as Michelle

Liz Richman
as Miriam

Victor Kallett
as Zach

Jenna Herz
as Tali

Danny Chon
as Kyle

Ayelette Robinson
as Mrs. Fleischman

Jill Karrenbrock
as Rebecca

David Pevsner
as Ari