Susan is about to be married, but the wedding may get called off after her fiancé summons three former beaus. Each reveals a different portrait of Susan: one describes her as a naive country girl who reluctantly becomes an actress, another paints a picture of a gay party girl and and the third describes a serious intellectual.

Joan Fontaine
as Susan Darell

George Brent
as Roger Berton

Dennis O'Keefe
as Bill Anthony

Don DeFore
as Mike Ward

Rita Johnson
as Mona Kent

Walter Abel
as Richard Aiken

Byron Barr
as Chick

Mary Field
as Nancy

Francis Pierlot
as Uncle Jemmy

Lewis L. Russell
as Mr. Cusp
CinemaSerf
Four men all have one thing in common - they are totally infatuated with Joan Fontaine's title character. Thing is, none of them are in love with the same women - or, at least the same iteration of the same woman. She has presented each of them, over the years, with a different "Susan" but which mig...