A film crew in search of a new documentary project determines to find a wrongfully imprisoned death-row inmate. Enter Chauncey Ledbetter, a quirky and potentially gay prisoner convicted of murdering his high school show choir teacher. As filming of the documentary progresses, evidence increases that Chauncey might be guilty after all.

Rob Helms
as Kevin Langstrom

Bruce Daniels
as Randall Overbee

Joe Dietl
as Royce Cannon

Carrie Aizley
as Jocelyn Silverberg

Diane Delano
as Sgt. Dot Jenkins

Michael Irpino
as Chauncey Ledbetter

Kathy Jensen
as Suzy Pleasant

Jennifer Aniston
as Clove

Andrea Bendewald
as Dust

Tate Donovan
as Simon