A team of misfit intramural baseball players become important to a player who was overlooked in the MLB draft, as he tries to come to grips with his dashed dream.

Aaron Tveit
as John "Maz" Mazello

Tyler Hoechlin
as Johnathan "Dells" Dellamonica

Jay Hayden
as Vincent "Vinnie" Maltzan

Duke Davis Roberts
as Ty Dellamonica

Joseph Mazzello
as Pat Murray

Chace Crawford
as Arthur Barone

Ryan Pinkston
as Jonathan Garvey

Matt Bush
as David Stein

Manny Montana
as Zapata

Toby Hemingway
as Palacco