A plastic surgeon changes the face of a female convict to match that of the beautiful woman who broke his heart and left him. He marries the convict but trouble starts when his true love returns.

Paul Henreid
as Dr. Philip Ritter

Lizabeth Scott
as Alice Brent / Lily Conover

André Morell
as David

Mary Mackenzie
as Lily Conover, before surgery

John Wood
as Dr. John 'Jack' Wilson

Susan Stephen
as Betty

Arnold Ridley
as Dr. Russell

Diana Beaumont
as May

Cyril Smith
as Alf Bixby, Innkeeper

Terence O'Regan
as Pete Snipe
CinemaSerf
The problem with this rather mediocre tale is that the underlying premiss is really pretty far-fetched. Surgeon Paul Henreid has a brief assignation with a concert pianist (Lizabeth Scott) before she returns to her boyfriend "David" (Andre Morell). Obsessed with the woman, the physician carries out ...