Derek and Nancy Haysom were brutally murdered in their house in Lynchburg, Virginia, on March 30, 1985. Suspicion fell on their daughter Elizabeth and her boyfriend Jens Söring. They flee to Europe, but are caught and extradited to the U.S. Elizabeth is sentenced to 90 years in jail for incitement to murder, Jens Söring to two life sentences. Karin Steinberger, Marcus Vetter and their team spent over three years researching this case, which achieved world-wide notoriety. They uncovered new evidence, including the fact none of the blood samples found at the scene of the crime belonged to Jens Söring.

Imogen Poots
as Elizabeth Haysom (voice)

Daniel Brühl
as Jens Söring (voice)

Jens Söring
as Self

Gail Ball
as Self

Steven Rosenfield
as Self

Tom Elliott
as Self

Ricky Gardner
as Self

Gail Marshall
as Self

Chuck Reid
as Self

Carlos Santos
as Self