Six New Yorkers navigate love, commitment, and adulthood. When struggling novelist Sam takes in an abandoned boy he meets on the subway, his life begins to intertwine with a talented singer who challenges his bachelor ways. Meanwhile, his best friend Annie battles alopecia while torn between two drastically different men, and a long-term couple faces a crossroads that could alter their future together.

Josh Radnor
as Sam

Malin Akerman
as Annie

Kate Mara
as Mississippi

Zoe Kazan
as Mary Catherine

Pablo Schreiber
as Charlie

Tony Hale
as Sam #2

Michael Algieri
as Rasheen

Jakob Appelman
as School Boy

Dana Barron
as The Gynecologist

Richard Jenkins
as Paul Gertmanian