Beautiful Katie Lapp has always felt something missing in her simple Amish existence -- until a mysterious "Englisher" comes to Lancaster County looking for the baby girl she gave up for adoption 19 years ago.

Danielle Panabaker
as Katie Lapp

Sherry Stringfield
as Laura Mayfield-Bennett

Sarah Maine
as Jessica

Willie Stratford
as Theodore

Jason Loughlin
as Benjamin Lapp

Sandra Elise Williams
as Rebecca Lapp

Bill Oberst Jr.
as Samuel Lapp

Wyatt Lanier
as Jacob Beiler

Burgess Jenkins
as Bishop John Beiler

Dalton Parrish
as Hickory John Beiler