Goody Rickby has a child out of wedlock, but it dies when the father, Gillead Wingate, refuses to acknowledge the child or help the mother get medical aid. Wingate becomes one of the foremost figures in the witch hunts, and Goody plots her revenge with Dr. Nicholas, who is really the Devil.
Glenn Hunter
as Lord Ravensbane / The Scarecrow
Mary Astor
as Rachel
Osgood Perkins
as Dr. Nicholas
Maude Hill
as Goody Rickby
Frank Tweed
as Gillead Wingate
Dwight Wiman
as Richard Talbot
Thomas Chalmers
as The Minister